| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2014 | Darwin Barney | N.L. | Gold Gloves |
| 2014 | Jose Bautista | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2014 | C.j. Wilson | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2014 | Jason Kerns | N.L. | All-Star Coaching Staff |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2013 | R.a. Dickey | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2013 | Erick Aybar | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2013 | Joey Votto | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2013 | Jason Kerns | N.L. | All-Star Coaching Staff |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2012 | Santiago Casilla | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2012 | C.j. Wilson | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2012 | Jose Bautista | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2012 | Joey Votto | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2012 | Joey Votto | N.L. | Most Valuable Player |
| 2012 | Jason Kerns | N.L. | All-Star Coaching Staff |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2011 | Joey Votto | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2011 | C.j. Wilson | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2011 | Jose Bautista | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2011 | Carl Crawford | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2011 | Ryan Franklin | N.L. | Rolaids Reliever of the Year |
| 2011 | Jason Kerns | N.L. | All-Star Coaching Staff |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2010 | Carl Crawford | N.L. | Gold Gloves |
| 2010 | Eric Aybar | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2010 | Joey Votto | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2010 | Carl Crawford | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2009 | Joe Saunders | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2009 | Joey Votto | N.L. | Rookie of the Year |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2008 | Carl Crawford | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2008 | Khalil Greene | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2007 | Carl Crawford | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2007 | Mark Grudzielanek | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2007 | Jason Jennings | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2007 | Gary Matthews | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2006 | Carl Crawford | N.L. | Gold Gloves |
| 2006 | Livan Hernandez | N.L. | Gold Gloves |
| 2006 | Carl Crawford | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2006 | Dustin Hermanson | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2006 | Dustin Hermanson | N.L. | Rolaids Reliever of the Year |
| 2006 | Jason Kerns | N.L. | All-Star Coaching Staff |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2005 | Jesus Colome | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2005 | Carl Crawford | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2004 | Shea Hillenbrand | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2003 | Chris Singleton | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2002 | Damion Easley | N.L. | Gold Gloves |
| 2002 | Trevor Hoffman | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2001 | Trevor Hoffman | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |