| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2023 | Matt Olson | N.L. | Gold Gloves |
| 2023 | Matt Olson | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2023 | Evan Phillips | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2023 | Kyle Tucker | A.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2023 | Nigel Earhart | N.L. | All-Star Coaching Staff |
| Year | Name | League | Award |
| 2022 | Aaron Judge | N.L. | Gold Gloves |
| 2022 | Josh E. Bell | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2022 | Joey Gallo | N.L. | League All-Star – Reserve |
| 2022 | Aaron Judge | N.L. | League All-Star – Starter |
| 2022 | Nigel Earhart | N.L. | All-Star Coaching Staff |